Additional Definitive Proxy Soliciting Materials
ISS recommends voting against re-election of two directors citing ineffective internal controls; company disputes recommendation.
Select text to share a quote on X · sign in to keep highlights & notes in your BUR notes
The following information is being shared by Burford Capital Limited ("Burford", "we", "us" or "our") with holders of its ordinary shares beginning on April [28], 2025 in response to a recommendation by Institutional Shareholder Services ("ISS") in connection with the proposals included in Burford's definitive proxy statement (the "2025 Proxy Statement"), which was filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") on April 3, 2025 and is available at
ISS has recommended that shareholders vote against the re-election of two directors, namely Christopher Halmy (the Vice Chair and putative Chair in 2027) and Robert Gillespie. ISS' recommendation is based on a misunderstanding of facts that have been clearly explained previously to shareholders and also, in the case of Mr Halmy, a factual error about the date on which he joined Burford's board of directors (the "Board of Directors").
Notably, Glass Lewis does not concur with ISS' recommendation and has supported both directors' re-election to the Board of Directors.
We ask shareholders to disregard ISS' recommendation and re-elect Messrs Halmy and Gillespie to the Board of Directors.
ISS' entire analysis is as follows:
The company has had ineffective internal control over financial reporting since FY2021. This issue poses serious risks to shareholders and indicates that the audit committee has failed to provide sufficient oversight over the financial reporting process at the company over the past year. As such, support is not warranted to Audit Committee members Robert Gillespie and Christopher (Chris) Halmy.
What ISS appears to have done is to conflate two entirely different matters: (i) the modifications to Burford's valuation approach (which caused valuations to increase) that were driven by engagement with the SEC as extensively reported to shareholders and affected Burford's consolidated financial statements for the years ended December 31, 2020, 2021 and 2022; and (ii) the current reported material weakness in financial controls relating to a lack of available evidence to demonstrate the precision of management's review of the process to determine certain assumptions used in the measurement of the fair value of capital provision assets, which material weakness did not result in misstatements to our consolidated financial statements. Those matters are unrelated to each other and certainly do not provide any basis-even under ISS' own guidelines-for terminating two valuable and experienced directors. (Moreover, Mr Halmy was not even on the Board of Directors in 2021.) Glass Lewis agrees, having recommended a vote in favor of re-election of both Messrs Halmy and Gillespie to the Board of Directors.
As evident from their bios contained in the 2025 Proxy Statement, both Messrs Halmy and Gillespie are extremely qualified to serve as members of the Board of Directors and on the audit committee of the Board of Directors (the "Audit Committee"), with each having contributed significantly to the success of Burford. Mr. Gillespie helped to oversee Burford's listing on the New York Stock Exchange in 2020, with Burford having been the first publicly-traded legal finance company in the US, and the transition from reporting under the International Financial Reporting Standards to reporting under generally accepted accounting principles in the United States, which has been proven successful with over 80% of trading volume now occurring in the United States. Together, Messrs Halmy and Gillespie oversaw the engagement with the SEC that led to the successful modification of Burford's valuation framework and we believe solidified Burford's position as a leader across the legal finance industry. In addition, Messrs Halmy and Gillespie have guided Burford through the successful transition from "foreign private issuer" to a US domestic public company with the filing of Burford's first Annual Report on Form 10-K this March 2025.
We also ask shareholders to vote in favor of our executive compensation.
While we are addressing ISS' recommendations, we would also note that ISS has recommended a vote against executive compensation because ISS dislikes the use of carried interest allocations, just as ISS regularly recommends against compensation at other alternatives firms including Ares, TPG, Carlyle and Apollo on the same basis. We think this position is misguided and we believe-as do the world's largest and most successful alternative managers-that carried interest allocations align the interests of management and shareholders, in that management is only paid carried interest allocations when investments produce profitable cash flow without regard to any fair value or accounting movements. We encourage shareholders to vote in favor of our executive compensation, which is consistent with our approach to compensation for many years, has been fully described to shareholders and is commensurate with our cash performance.
Bios of Messrs Halmy and Gillespie
Each of Mr. Gillespie and Mr. Halmy is an independent and qualified member of the Audit Committee. Mr. Halmy is an independent non-executive director, the Vice Chair of the Board of Directors, the Chair of the Audit Committee and a member of the Compensation Committee. He has served as a director on the Board of Directors since May 2022. Mr. Halmy was most recently a Senior Advisor to McKinsey & Company from August 2019 to December 2024, focusing predominantly on auto lending. Prior to McKinsey & Company, Mr. Halmy was the Chief Financial Officer of Ally Financial Inc. (NYSE: ALLY), where he led the multinational initial public offering and was responsible for Ally Financial Inc.'s $25 billion investment portfolio. Before that, Mr. Halmy worked in various finance, accounting and treasury roles at Bank of America and JP Morgan. He began his career as a senior accountant at Deloitte. Mr. Halmy also serves as an independent member of the board of directors, the chair of the finance and investment committee and a member of the audit committee of Western Alliance Bancorporation (NYSE: WAL) and as the independent chair of the board of directors and the chair of the audit committee of Mercury® Financial LLC. He has previously served as an independent member of the board of directors of Mosaic Sustainable Finance Corp., a financing company focusing on residential solar energy, and an independent member of the board of directors of Spectrum Automotive Holdings Corporation prior to its sale in 2021. Mr. Halmy is a Certified Public Accountant and earned his MBA and undergraduate degrees from Villanova University. Mr. Halmy's extensive experience in finance, accounting and treasury and professional background as the Chief Financial Officer of a large, publicly traded financial institution make him a valuable member of the Board of Directors.
Mr. Gillespie is an independent non-executive director and the Chair of the Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee and a member of the Audit Committee. He has served as a director on the Board of Directors since May 2020. Mr. Gillespie had a lengthy career as an investment banker, spending more than 25 years at UBS and its predecessors in a range of senior positions, including Vice Chairman, Chief Executive Officer, EMEA, and Joint Global Head of Investment Banking, while also serving on the Group Managing Board and the Management Committee for many years. Mr. Gillespie started his career as a Chartered Accountant at PricewaterhouseCoopers. Mr. Gillespie is the chair of the board of directors and a member of the audit committee of the UK Export Finance, a ministerial department of the UK government that functions as the export finance agency, and also serves as the non-executive chair of the board of directors of Spirit Yacht Holdings Ltd. He has previously served as a non‐executive director of NatWest Group plc (formerly known as Royal Bank of Scotland plc) and certain of its principal subsidiary companies and was the chair of NatWest Group plc's remuneration committee and a member of NatWest Group plc's audit, risk and nominating and governance committees. In addition, Mr. Gillespie also served as the Director General of the UK Takeover Panel, a non-executive director of Citizens Financial Group Inc. and Ashurst LLP, a law firm, and as the non-executive chair of the board of directors of Boat Race Company Ltd., Somerset House Trust and the Council of Durham University, from which he graduated with a degree in economics. Mr. Gillespie's extensive experience in finance, accounting, risk management and governance and years of experience serving on the boards of directors of both public and private companies make him a valuable member of the Board of Directors.
Cleaned text: letterheads, contacts and legal notices removed. View the original announcement ↗ · Company filings. Not investment advice.