CatalystWireBeta
BENCHMARK · TESTED 16 NOVEMBER 2026

ChatGPT, Claude – or Claude with CatalystWire?

We asked the same three questions about UK small caps four ways and checked every answer against the regulatory announcements. Your AI is clever. What it lacks is the filings – all of them, up to today, in numbers it can compare.

Filings, not forumsWeb search mixes blogs, forums and promotional sites – one question about Shearwater pulled in 33 websites. We read the regulatory announcements and the accounts in them, nothing else.
Every RNS since 2023Your AI reads 10–30 web pages per answer and favours what gets attention. We have read every announcement of ~951 UK small and mid caps.
Numbers you can screenA screen needs every company's figures in one table. Asked for cash-rich AIM shares on a low multiple, ChatGPT found 1 of 3 – and read it on our site. Claude with web search found none.
Today's figuresTender offers, disposals, a new CEO: our numbers move with every announcement, not once a year. ChatGPT quoted NCC's net cash at £230m – a June figure, before £185m went back to shareholders.
Remembers and keeps watchA chat starts from zero and only answers when you ask. We keep your briefing, your last walkthrough and the points you track – read every new RNS for you and email you when something changes.
The catch, flaggedGoing-concern notes, one-off profits, failed data checks and what the price assumes – before you rely on a figure. Every line linked to the sentence it came from.
Can't I just tell ChatGPT to use only RNS sites? It cuts the noise, but the AI then can't read most filings: limited to RNS sites in our test, Claude missed Shearwater's annual results and confirmed none of the three screen matches. In the ChatGPT and Claude apps such a rule is also only a request in your prompt, not a filter.
1 · Numbers across every company

A screen

“List UK AIM shares with a market cap between £20m and £200m that hold net cash worth more than 30% of their market value, have positive free cash flow over the last twelve months, and trade below 8x EV/EBIT.”

What the filings say: 3 shares qualify: Serabi Gold (1.8x EV/EBIT), Kooth (6.0x) and Gattaca (6.3x). SRB → KOO → GATC →

ChatGPTfree, web search 1 of 3 · ~30 s
Found Gattaca – its source was catalystwire.co. Said itself the list is not complete.
Claudeweb search 0 of 3 · 4 min
Searched 32 websites (Substack posts, value-stock blogs, an Indian screener), checked five companies, none qualified – then listed names “from memory”.
Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites 0 of 3 · 3½ min
Could not find share prices or share counts on RNS sites; confirmed none.
Claude + CatalystWireconnected 3 of 3 · 35 s
All three, with the catch for each: Serabi cut its production guidance and its mine licence runs out on 29 January 2027.
Shows: Numbers you can screenFilings, not forums
2 · Many qualitative criteria

A judgement call

“Which UK small caps are in the middle of a real strategic change – a new CEO, a strategic review, a disposal or a break-up – and still have the balance sheet to see it through? Give me the 5 most interesting.”

What the filings say: There is no single right list – but the facts can be checked. NCC Group, for one, appointed a new CEO on 27 October 2026 and expects net cash of c.£53m after returning £185m. NCC trading update and new CEO, 27 Oct 2026 →

ChatGPTfree, web search 5 names · ~30 s Well argued, but NCC's cash at “approximately £230m” – June's figure – and no word of the new CEO. No valuation; it suggested building one next.
Claudeweb search 2 names · 3 min Two it could verify plus a £1.2bn bank, then ran out of searches.
Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites 2 names · 2 min NCC with today's figures and Aptitude – then ran out of searches.
Claude + CatalystWireconnected 5 names · 73 s Five, four more ruled out with the reason. Found less-covered names (Strix, Oxford Metrics, Next 15) and flagged a going-concern warning at Next 15.
Shows: Today's figuresEvery RNS since 2023The catch, flagged
3 · A single fact check

One company's figures

“What are Shearwater Group's latest full-year revenue, operating profit and net cash, and roughly what is the business worth once its cash is taken off?”

What the filings say: FY to 30 June 2026 (results of 27 October 2026): revenue £42.3m, operating loss £0.4m, net cash £5.6m, enterprise value about £10m. Shearwater FY26 results →

ChatGPTfree, web search 4 of 4 · ~20 s
All correct, from the results announcement.
Claudeweb search 4 of 4 · 50 s
All correct – drawn from 33 websites, Substack blogs and stock-tip sites among them.
Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites 2 of 4 · 1 min
Could not open the annual results on the RNS sites, used July's trading update instead: no operating profit, no enterprise value.
Claude + CatalystWireconnected 4 of 4 · 21 s
All correct, plus what matters around them: the year before covered 15 months, and £32m of receivables make the cash swing.
Fair to say: One company with a fresh report is where your AI alone does well. The difference shows when the question spans many companies, reaches past the last report, or needs a judgement.
Shows: Filings, not forums

Try it in your own AI

Connect CatalystWire to Claude or ChatGPT in one step – sign in with your e-mail, no API key.

Claude ChatGPT

How to connect →

How we tested

Share this quote

Quote card
Post on X WhatsApp Download image

The link opens this announcement with the quote highlighted. Quotes are checked against the original text.

Add a note