ChatGPT, Claude – or Claude with CatalystWire?
We asked the same three questions about UK small caps four ways and checked every answer against the regulatory announcements. Your AI is clever. What it lacks is the filings – all of them, up to today, in numbers it can compare.
A screen
What the filings say: 3 shares qualify: Serabi Gold (1.8x EV/EBIT), Kooth (6.0x) and Gattaca (6.3x). SRB → KOO → GATC →
| ChatGPTfree, web search | 1 of 3 · ~30 s | Found Gattaca – its source was catalystwire.co. Said itself the list is not complete. |
| Claudeweb search | 0 of 3 · 4 min | Searched 32 websites (Substack posts, value-stock blogs, an Indian screener), checked five companies, none qualified – then listed names “from memory”. |
| Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites | 0 of 3 · 3½ min | Could not find share prices or share counts on RNS sites; confirmed none. |
| Claude + CatalystWireconnected | 3 of 3 · 35 s | All three, with the catch for each: Serabi cut its production guidance and its mine licence runs out on 29 January 2027. |
A judgement call
What the filings say: There is no single right list – but the facts can be checked. NCC Group, for one, appointed a new CEO on 27 October 2026 and expects net cash of c.£53m after returning £185m. NCC trading update and new CEO, 27 Oct 2026 →
| ChatGPTfree, web search | 5 names · ~30 s | Well argued, but NCC's cash at “approximately £230m” – June's figure – and no word of the new CEO. No valuation; it suggested building one next. |
| Claudeweb search | 2 names · 3 min | Two it could verify plus a £1.2bn bank, then ran out of searches. |
| Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites | 2 names · 2 min | NCC with today's figures and Aptitude – then ran out of searches. |
| Claude + CatalystWireconnected | 5 names · 73 s | Five, four more ruled out with the reason. Found less-covered names (Strix, Oxford Metrics, Next 15) and flagged a going-concern warning at Next 15. |
One company's figures
What the filings say: FY to 30 June 2026 (results of 27 October 2026): revenue £42.3m, operating loss £0.4m, net cash £5.6m, enterprise value about £10m. Shearwater FY26 results →
| ChatGPTfree, web search | 4 of 4 · ~20 s | All correct, from the results announcement. |
| Claudeweb search | 4 of 4 · 50 s | All correct – drawn from 33 websites, Substack blogs and stock-tip sites among them. |
| Claudeweb search limited to RNS sites | 2 of 4 · 1 min | Could not open the annual results on the RNS sites, used July's trading update instead: no operating profit, no enterprise value. |
| Claude + CatalystWireconnected | 4 of 4 · 21 s | All correct, plus what matters around them: the year before covered 15 months, and £32m of receivables make the cash swing. |
Try it in your own AI
Connect CatalystWire to Claude or ChatGPT in one step – sign in with your e-mail, no API key.
How we tested
- All runs on 16 November 2026, each question asked once, in a new chat.
- ChatGPT: the free version, signed out, with web search. Claude: Claude Opus 5.5 with web search (up to 12 searches per step); a second run limited web search to investegate.co.uk and londonstockexchange.com; a third used the same model connected to CatalystWire.
- Answers are shortened here. Every figure we quote was checked against the company's own announcements.
- Not investment advice. The companies are examples from the tests, not recommendations.